Shaun’s Transphobia in the UK RESPONSE (Part 1)



Views:874|Rating:3.01|View Time:21:19Minutes|Likes:53|Dislikes:35
OK so I’ll include this in the comment too but:

This video was done almost 24 hours ago at this point but every time I tried to render it it would get stuck at one specific frame and I couldn’t get it to work.

That frame was in the second half of the video so I was thinking I could just upload the first half, but I thought… No. It’s too essential for the video to be viewed as one holistic argument, and dividing it into two would just ruin that.

I thought that last night. Now it’s late afternoon of the next day and here’s the first half of the video. Second half coming soon. Just expect this video to end suddenly and abruptly in such a manner as to totally interrupt the flow of the video.

You may also like...

16 Responses

  1. Bibi says:

    part 2! part 2! 😀

  2. Leighanna Rose Walsh says:

    "Shaun's content was great until he made a video defending the people I don't like also I'm not a transphobe because I say so"

  3. M Marrone says:

    If womanhood is "socially constructed based on biology" wouldn't it mean that society can re frame what womanhood or manhood means?

    Is your position that trans women aren't women until after society shifts enough to include them in that category?

  4. Hotel July says:

    "Decision to be trans"? That's like saying "decision to be gay". And yet in this same video you said if something seems inconsistent or hypocritical, it's because you've misunderstood something. Your reasoning is inconsistent right off the bat. Unless you think being gay is a choice in which case… yikes. Later on you talk about women specifically fearing sexual assault from black men. How is that not comparable to specifically fearing transwomen? If fearing black men specifically is the result of racism, then fearing transwomen specifically must be a result of transphobia. Though if the woman in question has had bottom surgery, that should mean there isn't any problem at all as far as penises being used as tools of oppression are concerned. Also, why are you willing to listen to women, but only SOME woman? Why not listen to transwomen and what they have to say? Or if you don't think transwomen are women, why not listen to transmen? I couldn't help but notice you didn't mention transmen once.

  5. Speed Nova says:

    I don't know how this is difficult for people to understand.

  6. thealleykittens says:

    This is brilliant! Thank you. Captures my thoughts exactly.

  7. pooflavouredchocolate says:

    Great video

  8. leopard prints says:

    Here from the GC reddit sub. Subscribed!

  9. Plexico Jackson says:

    You complain about being misconstrued. Shaun isn't comparing women to segregation whites. Shaun is comparing woman who are against trans people being in their spaces to segregation white people, and he is comparing trans people to black people. your statement of "people with penises" is reductionist which makes your earlier complaint about reductionism earlier even more hypocritical, and this also does not include trans women who have undergone surgery. The saying goes don't have your mind so open that shit gets in. You exemplify this perfectly. Men without penises? Think you might need a little bit more nuance in your reductionism, and yes you are an effective transphobe. You should do a re look and see if you start recycling conservative arguments.

  10. Liam Fred says:

    Great video

  11. Haxa says:

    Ben Shapiro wearing a bad feminist costume. Make sure to say "Facts don't care about your feelings" in part 2, please.

  12. Ban Landorus says:

    Wow. This is really, really bad. I feel compelled to throw together a response video to this nonsense but with it cutting out halfway it’s hard to really pin down where you’re going with this.

    My first though would be, how do you reconcile totally skipping the counter arguments Shaun makes about defining gender via genitals, namely those who suffered injury or the very existence of intersex people? Also your justification for entirely disregarding the experience of trans people on the basis of them being “white, with penises” totally ignores the existence of trans men, or any trans person of color.

    And good lord the comments about gender roles at the end are something else that I feel obligated to wait for the rest of the video before I address.

  13. cmmndrblu says:

    …I'm tired of the bullshit. I will fight for a transperson to not face discrimination and not live in fear of violence. But I will never be supportive of compelled speech. Biology is the qualifying category of being a man and being a woman. Trans means you feel you were born in the wrong body. The rest is made up.
    Biology in terms of skin colour is clearly the categorical factor of belonging to a group named by skin colour. Similarly biology in terms of genitalia is descriptive.
    Masculine and feminine roles are ascribed to people on the basis of their biological sex but the roles themselves, regardless
    of whether they are based on biological differences or not, are malleable.
    Saying that a trans-woman is a feminised man or that a trans-man is a masculinised woman is not inaccurate and since these are not inaccurate.
    The whole dialogue around this all comes from the assumption that everyone is a transphobic until proven otherwise…

  14. Latte Cat says:

    Fantastic video! I've subbed.

  15. Nicole says:

    Good video!

  16. King Ar-Pharazôn says:

    OK so I'll include this in the description too but:

    This video was done almost 24 hours ago at this point but every time I tried to render it it would get stuck at one specific frame and I couldn't get it to work.

    That frame was in the second half of the video so I was thinking I could just upload the first half, but I thought… No. It's too essential for the video to be viewed as one holistic argument, and dividing it into two would just ruin that.

    I thought that last night. Now it's late afternoon of the next day and here's the first half of the video. Second half coming soon. Just expect this video to end suddenly and abruptly in such a manner as to totally interrupt the flow of the video.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *